How many times have you been in a conversation with a colleague, and they started giving you suggestions? Each one sounds great, you think they could work in your room, but then you walk away from the conversation and nothing has stuck. All those great ideas went in your ears, passed through your brain, and then disappeared into the ether. No amount of thought can bring them back, and you feel embarrassed to go back to the colleague because you think that they might be offended that you didn’t remember the first time.
For all of us, there’s this idea called cognitive load. Cognitive load refers to the total amount of mental effort being used in the working memory. When you were talking with that colleague and they were sharing more and more ideas with you, it was causing your brain more and more of a cognitive load. In that moment, your brain is kind of like a cup – it can only hold so much new information before it begins to overflow.
Now, if each of us struggles cognitively to hold on to multiple ideas in a short conversation, how does this translate to our students? In a lot of the research on cognitive load in children, there is a clear difference between adult and child knowledge. Because of the differences in knowledge, children have to make a greater effort to simply process what is coming in, which means that their cognitive load will be exceeded more quickly.
I know that there were times as a teacher when I might have a student ask me a question. As I was answering the question, I might give more detail than was entirely necessary in order for students to better understand. Then, a few minutes later the student would ask the same question. At the time, it was frustrating – “Come on, I just told you that!” but I now understand that by giving the extra details, I was causing too heavy of a cognitive load on my students.
So, what does that mean for us? As we talk with students – whether we are giving them feedback on classwork, discussing their behavior, or making suggestions, we need to keep it short and to the point. In a recent post from Matt Miller, he suggested using the sandwich technique:
- A compliment (positive feedback)
- A change they could make
- Another compliment (more positive feedback)
Is it possible that we could suggest 17 corrections? Sure! But if we make all 17 at one time, the student will be overwhelmed, and none will get done. Pick your main point, your main concern, and focus on that. Once the student has shown that they understand your initial change, then maybe attack one of the other 17 things.
Meaningful feedback to students is one of the best ways to increase learning outcomes for our students. Give that feedback in the moment – while you’re walking around and peaking over shoulders, and keep it to the point. Students will learn and grow.
What are some of the strategies you use to give feedback to your students? Share with us in the comments below. If you’re looking for a few new ways to give quick feedback to your students, check out this awesome post from Matt Miller: